It starts the same way every time: perfect control, then complete collapse.

Discover Why You Can't Stop Binge Eating (It's Not Willpower)

You know the cycle by now.

Six days of perfect control. Every calorie calculated, every meal planned, every moment of hunger pushed through with discipline. You feel virtuous when you hit your target, even if you also feel exhausted, irritable, and obsessed with food.

Then day seven arrives.

Something shifts. The rigid control you've maintained all week suddenly dissolves. You eat everything-not because you planned to, but because you can't stop. The next morning, you wake up feeling defeated, ashamed, and determined to be even stricter this week to make up for it.

If this pattern sounds familiar, you've probably blamed yourself. You assume you lack willpower, that you just need more discipline, that if you could just be more controlled, the binges would stop.

Here's what almost no one tells you: You're blaming the wrong thing.

Why Blaming Willpower Is Wrong

When you binge eat, the natural conclusion seems obvious. You broke your rules. You lost control. You failed.

The logical solution? Be stricter. Count calories more carefully. Create tighter rules. Exercise more to compensate. Your ex-girlfriend with anorexia managed to stay controlled-maybe you just need to apply her techniques more rigorously.

So you do. You restrict harder. You calculate more precisely. When you can't go to the gym because of an injury, you immediately cut your food intake even further to compensate.

But here's the question that should make you pause: If lack of willpower was really the problem, what would you expect to happen to your binges over time?

They should decrease, right? Get less intense? Happen less frequently?

Instead, you've been doing this for months, and the binges are getting worse. More intense. More out of control. Despite all your discipline during the week, the pattern is intensifying rather than improving.

So what's actually happening here?

What Your Body Can't Tell You About Restriction

Let me ask you a different question.

Imagine you're observing an animal in the wild. For six days, that animal has limited access to food-just barely enough to survive, but constant hunger, constant searching, constant thinking about the next meal.

On day seven, that animal suddenly finds abundant food.

What would you predict the animal does?

It eats as much as possible while the food is available. Because from a biological standpoint, it has no idea when the next meal is coming. The body's response to scarcity is to capitalize on abundance when it appears.

Now here's the counterintuitive truth that changes everything:

Your body cannot distinguish between intentional calorie restriction and actual environmental famine.

When you restrict your food for six days-when you're hungry, irritable, thinking about food constantly, calculating every calorie to make them last-your body interprets this exactly the same way it would interpret a genuine food shortage.

You're not experiencing a famine. But your body thinks you are.

Research on eating disorders consistently demonstrates this: dietary restraint is one of the primary predictive factors for binge eating. When people restrict their food intake to make it last longer, they significantly increase their risk of binge eating when resources become available again. Studies examining this pattern found that variable food access creates a feast-or-famine cycle where restriction alternates with binge eating-not because of willpower failures, but because of how the human body is wired to respond to perceived scarcity.

During those six days of restriction, here's what's happening inside you:

• Your body is experiencing consistent hunger and fatigue
• Your mind is obsessing over food because it's scarce
• Mental exhaustion builds from constant calculation and rule-following
• Physical hunger intensifies
• Your system is primed for what researchers call a "scarcity response"

Then on day seven, when you finally eat something outside your strict plan, your body doesn't see a small deviation from your calorie target. It sees the end of a famine. And it responds exactly the way it's designed to: by driving you to eat as much as possible while food is available.

Why Restriction Creates the Binge Problem

This is the hidden cause that almost everyone misses:

Your restriction isn't solving your binge eating problem. Your restriction IS your binge eating problem.

The binges aren't happening despite your discipline. They're happening because of your discipline.

Every time you restrict, you're essentially telling your body: "Food is scarce. We're in survival mode." Your body responds by increasing hunger signals, intensifying food thoughts, and preparing to capitalize on any opportunity to eat. When that opportunity arrives-whether it's a planned "cheat day" or an unplanned moment when your rigid rules slip-the biological drive to binge is overwhelming.

This explains why the pattern you've experienced makes perfect sense:

• Why you think about food constantly during restriction (your brain is wired to focus on scarce resources)
• Why the binges feel uncontrollable (you're fighting against a biological survival response)
• Why being even stricter makes it worse (more restriction = stronger scarcity signal = more intense binges)
• Why this can continue for months without improvement (the cycle is self-perpetuating)

Studies examining the cognitive and behavioral pathways to binge eating have identified a clear pattern: when people assign morality to foods and tie self-worth to eating, their days become governed by strict food rules. This leads to mental exhaustion, physical hunger, and inevitable "slip-ups." But here's the critical finding: among individuals who recently binged, fasting and restriction actually increase their risk of future binge eating.

You're not failing at restriction. Restriction is failing you.

The Exercise Compensation Mistake That Keeps You Stuck

Now let's look at the other piece of this puzzle: exercise.

You mentioned something revealing in your pattern. When you ate more, you felt you had to exercise more. It wasn't about enjoyment or health-it was about earning the right to eat, about compensating, about undoing the "damage."

When you fractured your wrist and couldn't do your usual cardio routine, what did you immediately do?

You restricted your food even more severely. Because in your mind, if you couldn't burn off calories through exercise, you had to prevent them from entering your body in the first place.

You dropped to 63 kilograms at 184 centimeters tall-significantly underweight by any medical standard. Yet when you looked in the mirror, you still saw flaws that needed fixing. You still saw the double chin. You still thought you needed to lose more.

Here's what research on compulsive exercise in eating disorders reveals:

Compensatory exercise-exercising specifically to "undo" eating-is one of the strongest predictors of poor outcomes and relapse in eating disorders.

It affects up to 80% of people with anorexia nervosa and 55% of people with bulimia nervosa. And systematic reviews of treatment approaches consistently find that this compensatory pattern maintains the disorder rather than helping recovery.

Think about your gym sessions before the injury. Were you looking forward to them? Or did you feel compelled, anxious if you missed a day, obligated to complete them like a debt you owed?

That shift-from movement as enjoyment to exercise as punishment or repayment for eating-is the signature of compensatory exercise. And it keeps you trapped in the exact same cycle as food restriction: more eating requires more compensation, which reinforces the idea that eating is something to be undone rather than something normal and necessary.

Why Rigid Rules Backfire

You've avoided social dinners and drinks five or six times recently because you couldn't pre-calculate the calories. You've turned down your girlfriend's invitations to try new restaurants because you can't find nutritional information online.

The rigid rules feel like safety. Like control. Like the thing preventing complete chaos.

But here's what research on eating behavior patterns has discovered:

Rigid dietary strategies are associated with eating disorder symptoms, mood disturbances, excessive concern with body size, and-paradoxically-loss of control over eating.

Meanwhile, flexible dietary approaches show the strongest correlation with absence of overeating, lower body mass, and lower levels of depression and anxiety.

Studies specifically examining rigid versus flexible cognitive restraint found that rigid restraint is positively associated with disinhibition (loss of control), while flexible restraint shows a negative or null association. In other words, the stricter your rules, the more likely you are to lose control. The more flexible your approach, the less likely you are to binge.

Why?

Because rigid rules create all-or-nothing thinking.

If you tell yourself you can never have pizza, what happens when you finally do have a slice? The rules are already broken. You've already "failed." So why not eat the entire pizza? Why not add breadsticks and dessert? The day is already ruined-might as well make it count before you go back to restriction tomorrow.

This is the cognitive trap that research identifies: when you frame foods as forbidden and tie your self-worth to perfect adherence, any deviation feels catastrophic. The mental framework shifts from "I ate something unplanned" to "I'm out of control" to "I've already failed, so nothing matters now."

Flexible eating-where you allow all foods and track occasionally rather than constantly-doesn't trigger this all-or-nothing response. You can have pizza at a social dinner because pizza isn't forbidden. You can enjoy it, stop when you're satisfied, and move on with your evening without compensating the next day.

What This Pattern Reveals About Your Whole Life

You mentioned something else that connects all of this: "I'm never particularly happy, satisfied, or relaxed. Always chasing, never feeling right."

Look at how this mindset shows up everywhere:

• Even when you hit your calorie target, you think you should have aimed lower
• Even when you complete your gym session, you wonder if you should have done more
• Even at 63kg and 184cm (severely underweight), you see excess weight in the mirror
• Nothing is ever good enough

The same pattern that drives your eating-the rigid rules, the constant compensation, the assumption of worst-case scenarios-is the pattern driving your entire experience of life.

You used to see meals as relaxation time, as a break from everything. Now they're another source of stress, calculation, and fear.

You're missing time with friends, experiences with your girlfriend, normal moments of life-all because the rigid system has convinced you that perfect control is possible and necessary.

But you're not in control at all. The rules control you.

What Research Shows Actually Breaks the Cycle

Recent research on breaking binge-restrict cycles shows that cognitive-behavioral approaches specifically designed for eating disorders (CBT-enhanced, or CBTe) demonstrate substantial benefit. These approaches work not by increasing discipline or tightening rules, but by addressing the thoughts and behaviors that maintain the cycle.

The treatment doesn't focus on willpower. It focuses on understanding that restriction is the problem, not the solution.

Here's what the research consistently shows about recovery:

1. Increase in flexible cognitive restraint during intervention relates to better outcomes and well-being. Greater increases in flexible restraint are associated with decreased psychological distress.

2. Addressing compulsive exercise requires reframing movement from compensation to enjoyment. Physical therapy and supervised exercise can help carefully reintroduce movement to support recovery and enhance body awareness, rather than using it to "undo" eating.

3. Cognitive distortions-particularly catastrophic thinking and tying self-worth to eating/body-must be identified and restructured. Thoughts like "If I gained weight, no one would love me" or "If I can't calculate the calories, I'll lose all control" are distortions, not reality.

4. Exposure to previously avoided situations is essential. Going to social meals, eating foods without knowing exact calorie counts, and resisting the urge to compensate afterward-these experiences teach your system that eating normally doesn't lead to catastrophe.

How to Start Breaking the Pattern Today

You mentioned your girlfriend has asked you three times to try a new restaurant with her.

Go.

Not because you've figured out the menu in advance. Not because you've calculated how to restrict the next day to compensate. But because she wants to spend time with you, and food is supposed to be fuel and enjoyment, not punishment or fear.

Here's your framework for that meal:

Before: Remind yourself that this one meal will not define your body. Your girlfriend wants to spend time with you, not watch you panic over a menu.

During: Order something that sounds good, not something with the fewest calories. Stay present in the conversation instead of calculating. Notice what genuine hunger and fullness feel like without the overlay of rules.

After: This is the hardest part-resist the urge to restrict the next day to "make up" for it. Resist the urge to add extra cardio. Just continue normally.

The compensation is what keeps the cycle going. Breaking the cycle means tolerating the discomfort of not compensating.

You can also start tracking something different: flexibility instead of perfection.

Each day, note one instance where you chose flexibility over a rigid rule:

• Ate when you were hungry rather than waiting for your scheduled time
• Chose a preferred food over the lowest-calorie option
• Skipped mirror-checking or calorie calculation
• Attended a social event involving food

Over time, gradually reduce your calorie counting from constant calculation to occasional awareness. The goal isn't to never have awareness of what you're eating-it's to shift from obsessive tracking to flexible attention.

Measure your success not by weight or perfect adherence to rules, but by behavioral flexibility:

• Are you attending social events involving food?
• Are binge episodes decreasing as regular eating stabilizes?
• Are you spending less time calculating, planning, and obsessing?
• Are you experiencing moments of genuine satisfaction with meals?

The Truth About Real Control

Real control isn't following rigid rules perfectly.

Real control is being able to go to dinner with your girlfriend and order what sounds good. It's being able to eat a meal and then move on with your day without calculating compensation. It's being able to look in the mirror occasionally instead of constantly, and not letting what you see determine your worth.

The system you've been using-the one you learned from someone with an active eating disorder-wasn't designed to promote health. It was part of an illness. You thought you could use the technique without the disorder, but the technique is the disorder.

Restriction creates binges.

Compensatory exercise maintains the disorder.

Rigid rules generate all-or-nothing thinking.

And none of it gives you the control you're seeking.

What gives you control is understanding that your body interprets restriction as famine, that binges are a biological response to perceived scarcity, and that flexibility-not rigidity-is what allows sustainable patterns.

What You're Really Afraid Of

The scariest part of letting go of rigid rules isn't the fear that you'll lose control.

It's that you've already lost control-to the rules themselves.

You're cycling between restriction and binge eating. You're avoiding friends. You're obsessing over every calorie. You're never feeling satisfied. Your life is shrinking around food fear.

The rules aren't protecting you from chaos. They're creating it.

What if you went to one meal this week without pre-calculating everything? What if you ordered based on preference, stayed present during the meal, and didn't restrict or compensate the next day?

It will feel uncomfortable. Your mind will scream that you need to calculate and control. The anxiety will be real.

But discomfort isn't danger.

Your body isn't failing you. The rigid system is failing you.

And now that you understand the real cause of the binge-restrict cycle-that restriction itself creates the biological drive to binge, that compensatory exercise maintains rather than solves the problem, that rigid rules paradoxically increase loss of control-you have the foundation for real change.

Not perfect change. Not immediate change.

But the kind of change that actually works: moving from rigidity to flexibility, from compensation to permission, from constant chasing to occasional contentment.

The research is clear. The pattern is clear. The path forward is clear.

You're not broken. The system you're using is broken.

Time to try something different.

---

What's Next

Stay tuned for more insights on your journey to wellbeing.